Taking a look at Ali Ishaqi Book on Oral History

Mohammad Droudian
Translated by: Fazel Shirzad

2020-05-12


I had the opportunity to read Mr. Ali Ishaqi's book on oral history. According to my research on the second volume of the book "Fundamental Issues of War in the Works of the Army and the Islamic Revolution Guard Corps", I found some very interesting and rare points in the book that led to the writing of this notes. The reason for the importance and value of the book, in my opinion, is Mr. Ishaqi's activity in the field of "eavesdropping", which was formed within the Guard Corps’ information structure and provided an important part of the Corps’ defense-offensive capability to design and command operations and achieve military goals. In this regard, Ishaqi is a unique "founder" with an accumulation of information and experience, in which part of the dimensions and layers of this book have been questioned and the way has been opened for deeper discussions that have not been studied in this book. Of course, I do not intend to review the book, but I think by removing some extra notes and reducing the pages, the book will be more fluent and readable.

The structure of Mr. Ishaqi's activity in eavesdropping and its value, according to what is stated in the book, is on three interconnected pillars, although in this conversation it has not been properly researched and revealed:

1-As Ishaqi lived in Iraq until his puberty, in addition to learning and mastering Arabic language, it caused him to be familiar with Iraqi culture and structure. This mentioned background was effective in the desire to work in intelligence system and knowing the enemy and led to the formation and organization of eavesdropping in the Islamic Revolution Guard Corps.

2-Spending his military service in the Imperial Guard Division, increased his abilities in terms of training, especially in the technical and listening section that the effects gradually became apparent.

3-Self-employed job and workshop management in repairing, buying and selling motorcycle, which has led to the recognition of social relations and the possibility of communicating with different sections of society and commanding the forces to face security crises in the country.

In my opinion, the method of focusing on the history of the Iran-Iraq war at the Sacred Defense Documentation and Research Center has influenced in oral history method, and there is no deep analysis because of its focus on events, the structure of issues based on people's thinking and behavior in practice. Assuming that events are the result of agent’s interaction of role in decision-making with structure and conditions, in oral history, focusing on events in conversation with commanders and combatants prevents the recognition of structures. In any case, it will be possible to modify and complete the methods by holding review sessions and reviewing the methodology of oral history and published books.



 
Number of Visits: 740


Comments

 
Full Name:
Email:
Comment:
 

The Levant Morning

The tradition of writing memoirs, diaries, notes, or travelogues is a valuable and important tradition among politicians, and especially among ambassadors and diplomats throughout the world. Iran is no exception, and we have been involved with it during the previous hundred years, although it has been accompanied by ups and downs. The Levant Morning, which is some memoirs of Dr. Hossein Amir-Abdullahian, a senior diplomat at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, ...
Book Review: “The Role of Saeed”

Dr. Saeed Keshanfallah in the Words of others

“Written memories and oral memories”
During the funeral of martyr Kamran Nejat-Ullahi on December 27, 1978, the Pahlavi regime military forces fired at the mourners and killed several people near the current Enqelab (Revolution) Square. Hossein Qashqai was one of the martyrs of that event, who graduated from the University of Tehran Faculty of Dramatic Arts in 1973 with a degree in theater and had written and staged several plays.

Arbaeen in Pakistan, 2020

Arbaeen had a different spirit in our country this year, because it coincided with a sharp difference between Shiites and some Salafis. Pakistani clerics insisted that all Shiites attend the gathering, because a few weeks ago, a number of Wahhabis and Salafis marched for three days to honor some of the Companions of the Prophet, as well as Yazid, and insulted the infallible and pure Ahl al-Bayt. They also threw stones ...
Presenting the book In the Color of Patience, Memoirs of Fatemeh Sadr

The Nature of Saddam and the Baath Party in Iraq

The sixth volume of the Oral History Anthology, Imam Musa Sadr Cultural Research Institute
The book In the Color of Patience is the memoirs of Fatemeh Sadr, the wife of Shahid Seyyed Mohammad Baghir Sadr and the sister of Imam Musa Sadr, was published by the Imam Musa Sadr Cultural Research Institute in September 2020. On the back cover of the book can be read: "This book is the narration of Fatemeh Sadr about the joyousness of her fathers house and the delights of Najaf along