Oral History Interview & Importance – Part 23
Arguments with the Narrator
Hamid Qazvini
Translated by Natalie Haghverdian
2017-9-26
One thing that the interviewer shall seriously avoid is long discussions and argument with the narrator. In some cases the narrator insists on the credibility of their information and perceptions and the interviewer has a different idea based on their sources of information. In such cases, both sides might insist on their position and interrupt the interview.
The following has to be stated:
- The main task of the interviewer is to jog the mind of the narrator to help them remember old memories and incidents they have witnessed; however such efforts shall not be imperious and controlling. Unfortunately we see interviewers that due to their knowledge and long experience have a top to bottom look and in case of any mistakes by the narrator brag about their information and humiliate the narrator to prove their perceptions.
- Mistakes in recounting the memories is an inevitable element in the oral history interviewer and requires patience. Nevertheless, time and number of incidents weaken the memory and information gets mixed up and result in faults by the narrator while recounting them and they might not acknowledge their mistake. Under such circumstances, the interviewer shall respectfully and with no long arguments point out the mistake and in case the narrator refuses to accept, the interviewer shall stop the argument and wait for an opportunity to provide enough evidence to prove his argument. In case it doesn’t work, a full description shall be provided as footnote by the narrator while publishing the article.
I remember that while interviewing a prominent social and cultural feature, he made a mistake. I pointed it out to be corrected but he didn’t accept it. Hence, I didn’t argue and in our next sessions tried to provide evidence and literature to prove it. Despite all the evidence he insisted on his position. In such cases there is nothing but patience and flexibility and definitions and elaborations shall be offered as annexes to the publications.
- Sometimes the narrator requires the interviewer to express their opinion on the subject matter or their idea of the memories recounted. Such cases are not an opportunity for arguments and challenges. Our opinion might differ but there is no need to start a long discussion and argument.
- The biggest mistake is to boast others’ opinion and create fronts in between. Such behaviors cripple the narrator’s self-confidence and in some cases it might be associated with a bad reaction by the narrator. Of course in a targeted interview, while asking questions, it is possible to make reference to other narrations but it shall not be in the form of arguments and quarrel.
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 1 - Oral History, Path to Cultural Dialogue
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 2 - Characteristics of an Interviewer
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 3 - Selecting a Subject
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 4 - Narrator Identification & Selection
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 5 - Goal Setting
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 6 - Importance of Pre-interview Data Collection
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 7 - To Schedule & Coordinate an Interview
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 8 - Required Equipment & Accessories
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 9 - Presentation is vital
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 10 - Interview Room
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 11 - Pre-interview Justifications
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 12 - How to Start an Interview
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 13 - Proper Query
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 14 - Sample Query
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 15 - How to ask questions?
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 16 - Body Languag
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 17 - Application of Body Language (1)
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 18 - Application of Body Language (2)
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 19 - Listening Carefully (1)
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 20 - Listening Carefully (2)
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 21- New Questions
Oral History Interview & Importance Part 22 - Duration
Number of Visits: 6363
The latest
- The 373rd Night of Memories – Part 6
- Memories of Farshid Eskandari
- Authenticating Oral History: From Possibility to Necessity
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 28
- An Interview with Members of an Iraqi Mawkib Present at the Gatherings in Tehran
- Memoirs of Manizheh Lashkari
- The 373rd Night of Memories – Part 5
- 100 Questions/27
Most visited
- 100 Questions/26
- The 373rd Night of Memories – Part 5
- 100 Questions/27
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 27
- An Interview with Members of an Iraqi Mawkib Present at the Gatherings in Tehran
- Memoirs of Manizheh Lashkari
- Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War Doctor – 28
- Memories of Farshid Eskandari
The Editor's Missing Place on the “Deck”
The book From Deck to Heaven offers a relatively fresh approach to examining the role of the Islamic Republic of Iran Army Navy (AJA) during the eight years of the Sacred Defense, published under the “Oral History of the Islamic Revolution” series. To compile this book, the esteemed author has utilized documentary research (referring to relevant archival centers and selecting documents) and field research ...An Exceptional Haft‑Seen Table
I wanted to celebrate the new year with my family. Together with two relief workers I boarded buses designated for transporting the wounded to Choubideh and received our mission orders. We waited for a helicopter to take us to Bandar Imam Khomeini. I was stationed near the helicopter’s touchdown zone and was slight in build. As the helicopter was about to land, I could not steady myself; the breeze generated by the rotor blades lifted me off the ground.Spring under the shadow of war
Composing the Spring special for the new year in the past years was mostly along with hope, nature’s rebirth and the promise of renewal of life. Spring has always been a reminder for returning of life and peace after the Winters’ cold. This year though, another atmosphere has settled over our land in the last days of Esfand (March).Excerpt from the Memoirs of Mohammad-Hadi Ardebilli
I registered for Konkour (university entrance exam), following the conclusion of high school. I was accepted into Tehran’s polytechnic (Amirkabir) university and began to study chemical and petrochemical engineering. There was a building named Jordan in the faculty in which religious students had prepared a small room as a house of prayer and did the noon and afternoon prayers in there.
