Group backs secrecy on NI tapes
12 March 2012
THE AMERICAN Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts has warned that disclosing tapes from an oral history project on the Troubles would render Ed Moloney and Anthony McIntyre liable to execution.
The civil liberties group, in a submission to the US Court of Appeals, also warned that handing over tapes of interviews with republicans, including former IRA prisoner Dolours Price, to British authorities would also leave these interviewees facing possible execution by the IRA. “A culture of death to informants pervades both sides of the Troubles, and it has, unfortunately, survived the Good Friday agreement,” it stated.
The intervention through an “amicus brief” by the group challenging a US district court ruling that interviews be handed over was welcomed by writer, journalist and former director of the so-called Belfast Project, Ed Moloney, and by former IRA prisoner and academic Anthony McIntyre, who carried out the republican interviews.
The project involved taped interviews with former republican and loyalist paramilitaries being lodged with Boston College on the agreement that they would be revealed only on the death of the interviewees. However, the British authorities are now seeking disclosure of some of the republican tapes, including the interviews given by Dolours Price. Boston College is challenging some of the demands but not the requirement to hand over the Price tapes.
The group said the US government had “cavalierly” remarked in its defence of releasing tapes that “the Price interview by Boston College has been widely known for more than a year and nothing has happened” to her or Mr Moloney, Mr McIntyre or others.
“If disclosure is made, there is a grave risk that retaliation will follow,” the group said. It also said that, notwithstanding the peace process, IRA rules forbade the disclosure of secrets by its members.
While the Provisional IRA has ended its campaign of violence, the civil liberties group noted that the Real IRA, in a statement, said that it “unlike the Provos . . . [wasn’t] prepared to tolerate traitors”. It is reported that the PSNI is seeking the Dolours Price tapes to determine if it can shed any light on who murdered Jean McConville in 1972.
GERRY MORIARTY
Thu, Mar 01, 2012
Number of Visits: 4564
Share
The latest
- Memories of Mohammad Boloori
- Call for Fundamental Questions in the Field of Oral History
- 100 Questions/49
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 49
- Jasem Ghazbanpour's narration of the first day of the war in Khorramshahr
- Memoirs of Ali Fadaei
- The Relationship Between Oral History and Biography
- 100 Questions/48
Most visited
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 48
- The Relationship Between Oral History and Biography
- 100 Questions/48
- Seventh Theory: The evolutionary duality of document and narrative
- Memoirs of Ali Fadaei
- Jasem Ghazbanpour's narration of the first day of the war in Khorramshahr
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 49
- 100 Questions/49
100 Questions / 43
How can narrators and interviewers reach a common understanding?We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.
Documentary Pathology of the US Embassy Documents
The Necessity of Scientific Rereading and Content Analysis of DocumentsMore than four decades have passed since the publication of the first collections of documents from the US Embassy in Tehran. However, despite the relatively easy access to this treasure trove of documents, systematic research exploitation of it has not been adequate. We still do not have a “comprehensive picture” of the content of these 11,000 documents.
100 Questions / 42
What is the importance of the narrator and interviewers shared understanding of the past in oral history?We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all the answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.
Validation: Challenges and Necessities
Where does truth stand in oral history? How can the correctness of a narrative be recognized? Does fact-checking matter? If there is exaggeration in the reporting of some accounts, how can it be detected? Is it possible to record an event accurately through the recording of a narrative? Readers and users of oral history works are often faced with these questions, and sometimes encounter doubts about some oral history works.
