Critique of Oral History Question 41
Hassan Beheshtipour
Machine Translation edited by Mandana Karimi
2026-7-29
As is the practice every week, the Oral History website sent oral history question number 41 to experts in this field and asked them to provide their answer in 100 words. In the meantime, Mr. Hassan Beheshtipour, an oral history activist and expert, found the question problematic. The following note explains the objection and the expert’s critical view of last week’s question.
41. What effect does nostalgia (a pleasant emotional feeling accompanied by a kind of longing for a situation in the past) have on the association of memories and the formation of narrative?
This question, in essence, has several serious challenges. First, the definition of nostalgia provided in parentheses is incomplete. Because it limits nostalgia only to the "past," when the word nostalgia originally means "the pain of being away from home," not "the pain of being away from the past. “Later, its concept expanded and the past became one of the subjects of nostalgia, but not it is only subject. Because a person may feel nostalgic for their birthplace, their ancestral home, a neighborhood, a language or dialect, a culture, a human community, and even a way of life that may still be part of it.
Second, nostalgia is not always pleasant. Psychologists today consider it a bittersweet emotion; that is, it contains two opposing feelings at the same time, the pleasure of remembering and the sadness of losing or being away. Sometimes the sadness aspect is much more pronounced than the pleasure.
Third, the element of "lack" is absent from this definition. What distinguishes nostalgia from simply remembering the past is the feeling of distance or loss? For example, if I only remember my elementary school days, this is a memory, but if I feel that that period, those people, that space, or that quality of life is no longer lost and irretrievable, and this feeling creates a sweet sadness in me, then we are dealing with nostalgia. Therefore, the main element of nostalgia is not simply the past, but the loss of something valuable.
Fourth, the question is not exactly clear. Is the narrative in this question, as in the previous questions, the effect of nostalgia on the formation of the narrative in the oral history in question? In that case, what is its relationship to the effect of nostalgia on memories?
Fifth, how can one provide a precise and correct answer to this question in a hundred words, which has at least four basic forms? But, if you assume that we accept the definition of nostalgia as follows: Nostalgia is a complex emotion mixed with longing, longing, and pleasure that arises as a result of a sense of distance or loss from a person, place, time, relationship, culture, or valuable experience, and usually, by remembering it, it also evokes a sense of continuity of identity and meaning in life in the individual.
Click here to view the source for the definition of nostalgia.
Number of Visits: 645
The latest
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 47
- Servants Narration of the Religious Rituals of the Holy Shrine of Imam Reza (AS) From Tradition to Lived Experience
- Memories of Nasrollah Fat’hian
- Memories of Hossein Ali Najafian
- 100 Questions/46
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 46
- Theory Six: The Inevitability of Perspective
- Memoirs of Behzad Rastegari
Most visited
- 374th Night of Remembrance - 2
- 100 Questions/ 45
- Theory Six: The Inevitability of Perspective
- Memoirs of Behzad Rastegari
- The Third Regiment: Memoirs of an Iraqi Prisoner of War - 46
- 100 Questions/46
- Memories of Hossein Ali Najafian
- Servants Narration of the Religious Rituals of the Holy Shrine of Imam Reza (AS) From Tradition to Lived Experience
100 Questions / 43
How can narrators and interviewers reach a common understanding?We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.
Documentary Pathology of the US Embassy Documents
The Necessity of Scientific Rereading and Content Analysis of DocumentsMore than four decades have passed since the publication of the first collections of documents from the US Embassy in Tehran. However, despite the relatively easy access to this treasure trove of documents, systematic research exploitation of it has not been adequate. We still do not have a “comprehensive picture” of the content of these 11,000 documents.
100 Questions / 42
What is the importance of the narrator and interviewers shared understanding of the past in oral history?We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all the answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.
Validation: Challenges and Necessities
Where does truth stand in oral history? How can the correctness of a narrative be recognized? Does fact-checking matter? If there is exaggeration in the reporting of some accounts, how can it be detected? Is it possible to record an event accurately through the recording of a narrative? Readers and users of oral history works are often faced with these questions, and sometimes encounter doubts about some oral history works.
