Various Narrations and Interpretations in Oral History
Compiled by: Mahia Hafizi
Translated by: Fazel Shirzad
2024-10-30
In order to learn more about the problems and challenges of producing oral history works or memoirs, the oral history website has conducted conversations with some experts and activists in this field, which will be presented to the audience in the form of short notes.
In oral history, sometimes the memories of a person are narrated and the topic of discussion is that person; but sometimes, oral history expresses an event or a topic. In this regard, if the focus of oral history is on the "subject", the more narratives we have, the better and more accurate results will be obtained, and the more we will understand the essence of the case.
One of the main differences between oral history and written history is that in oral history, the spirit that governs the event is narrated. In other words, oral history expresses the spirit of the event rather than the body of the event. In oral history, the details of the issue are discussed, and everyone expresses these details from their own perspective. Observing the event from different angles may be due to the way people think about an event.
Some people, because they do not have a correct understanding of this matter, consider the difference of narrations as a defect for oral history. If it is used correctly, it is not only a defect, but it will be a good thing for oral history.
It is a bonus for oral history when the narratives are different but not contradictory. The words of different people about the same event are not necessarily contradictory but different. The beauty of oral history is this difference; but because they do not pay attention to this issue and the work is not done correctly, the good turns into a bad.
In this regard, the correct interpretation of the event is also important. The difference in people's accounts of an event may be due to the time difference in observing that event. The narration of the person who observed the event before its beginning until the end is different from the narration of the person who started observing the event from the middle of the event. The more the oral history researcher asks about the same subject from different people, the better the result will follow. However, if several people talk about a topic, it will be more difficult to compile it, but the result will be more accurate. The editor in oral history is to put together an event narrated from the perspective of different people. It is often said that the basis of oral history is the interview, and we neglect editing; If the wrong editing, it ruins the right interview.
As it was said, the difference between the narrations is different from the contradiction. The contradiction occurs when the narrators of the same event tell two conflicting stories from the same point of view. Here, it is the responsibility of the oral history researcher to determine the correct action and narration with different methods for verifying the narrations. Of course, it should be noted that verification is not always necessary and not always possible!
Number of Visits: 1020








The latest
- The Compassionate Commander
- The Role of Recording Oral History During War: Yes or No
- Medal and Leave - 5
- The Unique Position of the Iranian Oral History Website
- A Brief Reference
- Clarifying the Current Situation; Perspectives of the Oral History Website
- The Oral History Weekly; A New Window
- The Days Long Past of this Tale
Most visited
- A Statistical Glance at the Oral History Archive of Iran
- In Memory of the Son of the Soil; A Clear Picture of Patience and Freedom
- Medal and Leave - 4
- The 370th Night of Memories – 1
- Towards the Thousandth Issue
- The Oral History Website and Its Position
- Structure of Oral History Weekly
- Oral History’s Deadlocks
Monafeghin: A New Deception
July-August 1989Following the discussions around the asylum of Iraqi prisoners of war in Iran during peace negotiations, the Iraqi side, not wanting to fall behind, launched their own campaign to offer asylum. At the outset, they attempted to attract prisoners by making grand promises ...
Supports from Guilds and Bazaars peaple
Memoirs of Haj Hossein FathiOur base of operations had become the Saheb al-Zaman Mosque in the Kamp-Lou neighborhood of Ahvaz. With the assistance of Brother Khani and his companions, we began preparing hot meals and sending them to the frontlines. We ourselves, along with several fellow merchants from the bazaar, entered the conflict zone, bringing warm clothing, ...
War Health
Narrated by Dr. Ali Mehrabi TavanaThe book War Health is an oral narrative by Dr. Ali Mehrabi Tavana, a commander in the health sector during the Sacred Defense era. This book, in the form of six chapters and twenty conversation sessions, covers the narrator’s life from birth to the end of the [Iranian] Eight-Year War. The interviews and compilation of the book were conducted ...
Agents in Search for the Fighter
[Interview with Fatemeh Amir Hosseini 2019/03/08.] The agents were always at our house. They would come day and night, turn the house upside down, mess up the library. For example, I remember we had the book Eqtesadona (Our Economy) by Mr. Sadr, and Imam Khomeini’s Resaleh (Treatise). We had many books—they would pack some of them up and take them away. Then the next day, they would knock again. Back then, our house was on Ghiyasi Street. We were really distressed.
