Theories about oral history narrated by artificial intelligence

Theory 9: Maximum usefulness

Machine Translation edited By Mandana Karimi

2026-11-19


Oral history, more than being an accumulation of narratives, is a field of methodical dialogue between memory, power, ethics, and representation. In the meantime, one of the challenges for researchers in this field is to move from “interview report” to “theoretical structure”; a question to which each expert, based on his or her experience and intellectual framework, gives a different answer.

 

If we provide the answers of 12 oral history experts - who have answered a specific question on the oral history website - to artificial intelligence, what patterns and repetitions will be obtained? Is artificial intelligence simply reflecting the consensus of opinions or will it arrive at a theory from the plurality of answers?

 

To find the result, we analyzed the experts’ answers with the help of DeepSeek artificial intelligence and came up with some theories. From now on, the theories extracted by artificial intelligence based on the experts' responses will be presented in order to open a new chapter in theorizing on the topic of oral history.

 

■■■

 

Theory Ninth: The Useful Maximum

Theoretical sentence:

The quantity of footnotes in oral history works is subject to the "economic law of necessity": neither absolute elimination nor incalculable excess, but "the minimum that removes ambiguity and the maximum that does not overwhelm the text with marginalia." The footnote has two distinct functions here: "referential" (validation and traceability) and "explanatory" (expression and context). Its quantitative indexing (for example, the number per thousand words) is neither possible nor desirable, because each text has a unique situation depending on the "sensitivity of the subject", "the level of expertise of the audience", "the skill of the interviewer during the conversation", "the degree of strangeness of the terms" and "the method of editing". The golden rule is this: every footnote must either be "traceable" or "understandable"; otherwise, it does not add value, but rather "burdens" the text. Theoretical Background:

 

This theory is based on the responses of 12 oral history experts (Gholamreza Azari Khakster, Mohammad Mehdi Behdarvand, Hassan Beheshtipour, Abolfazl Hassanabadi, Seyyed Mohammad Sadeq Feyz, Hamid Qazvini, Mohammad Mehdi Abdollahzadeh, Gholamreza Azizi, Abolfat’h Mo’men, Mohammad Mohsen Mushafi, Shafiqa Niknafs, and Seyyed Wali Hashemi) to the question, “Can an indicator be defined for the amount (quantity) of footnotes in oral history works?” The repetition of concepts such as "explanatory versus referential footnotes", "the risk of the margin dominating the text and disrupting the rhythm of the narrative", "the dependence of the quantity of footnotes on the level of the audience, the type of subject, and the editing method", "the need for the footnote to be concise, concise, and useful (what is the heart and soul)", "avoiding excess in number and volume", "the golden standard: each footnote should be either followable or understandable", "the possibility of determining a relative quantitative index (for example, 2 to 4 footnotes per thousand words for general narratives)", "the appropriateness of explanatory figures and terms (co-writing)", "the suggestion of an approximate volume of ten percent for footnotes", and "the role of the interviewer's skill in reducing the need for footnotes" in these responses has led artificial intelligence to the model you studied.

 

Click here to see the experts' initial answers to this question.

 



 
Number of Visits: 9



Share


 
Experts Answer to Oral History Questions

100 Questions/53

Should the interviewer point out inconsistencies in the narrative to the narrator during the interview?
We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.

Call for Fundamental Questions in the Field of Oral History

The Oral History of Iran website invites all researchers, experts, professors, and activists in the field of oral history to share their views and experiences with the audience on the most important questions in this field. We ask you to raise a maximum of 10 fundamental questions in the field of oral history that every researcher, interviewer, and oral history enthusiast should think about, and write an answer for each in about 200 words.
Experts Answer to Oral History Questions

100 Questions / 43

How can narrators and interviewers reach a common understanding?
We asked several researchers and activists in the field of oral history to express their views on oral history questions. The names of each participant are listed at the beginning of their answers, and the text of all answers will be published on this portal by the end of the week.

Documentary Pathology of the US Embassy Documents

The Necessity of Scientific Rereading and Content Analysis of Documents
More than four decades have passed since the publication of the first collections of documents from the US Embassy in Tehran. However, despite the relatively easy access to this treasure trove of documents, systematic research exploitation of it has not been adequate. We still do not have a “comprehensive picture” of the content of these 11,000 documents.