Oral History :: Rationalization Represents the Mastery of Compiler over Text

Rationalization of Oral History Books (part II)

Rationalization Represents the Mastery of Compiler over Text

Akram Dashtban
Translated by: Fazel Shirzad

2018-05-29


Note: Following report is based on an invitation in which history experts are asked questions about oral history. In this regard, one of experts, as his perspective, has answered to one of questions titled "The amount of rationalization and appendix in oral history books". We'll read these comments as follows.

Mohammad Javad Moradinia, general director of Office for the Development of Books and Reading Books of the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance and the director of Oral History Two-Quarterly, commented oral history site of Iran about rationalization of oral history's texts.

 

 

He spoke about the amount of rationalization and appendix in oral history books: As title showed, rationalization is an introduction of names, places, historical phenomena, the name of  book, and so on, which is ambiguous to addressee, and compiler bring explanation, based on valid documentation and references, in the footnotes of book.

Moradinia continues to state that there is no different between definition of rationalization in oral memory and oral history, and added: Although this two formats are distinct in definition, author uses the technique of rationalization in the compilation of work when s/he encounter with ambiguous and unknown terms.

Saying about functions of rationalization, he added: The rationalization of text shows that the compiler of book has mastered on it and has worked hard to make the text a useful and effective one. Otherwise, it eliminates the ambiguities of text and converts a work from an early to polished one, and becomes closer to a research work.

The director of Oral History Two-Quarterly said about weak points that threatens rationalization of oral history: If a text selected for rationalization is not documented or ambiguous, it will add disadvantages to book. It is not supposed to make topics more obscure by rationalization in book. If compiler has encountered with a name in narration and cannot explain it well or does not have a reliable explanation for information which he provided, s/he only adds to shortcomings of effect.

The proper extraction of content is related to interviewer, if interviewer submits subject in ambiguous or summary terms, this is the art of interviewer to keep interview climate, hold the dialogue, then ask questions and take answers and rationalized text. It is not necessarily supposed that rationalization and explanations are brought in the text only compiler.

Moradinia explained about the amount of rationalization: The amount of rationalization should be concise and useful and should not overcome the text; a line, for example, should not be explained in twenty lines. This is the art of author and compiler to state readers, what they intended, with minimal words and sentences and does not exceed its limits.

Iranian oral history website asks question to experts about oral history, and publish responses to readers. Total responses will have remarkable results. If you have any questions, please feel free to submit it via this page to read comments from experts of oral history!



 
Number of Visits: 277


Comments

 
Full Name:
Email:
Comment:
 

Oral History Is a Kind of Document

One of the questions that have always preoccupied historians of oral history is that: Is there any need to written documents and so on in recording oral history and compiling its text? An overview of types of documents and nature of oral history can answer this question. Most historical evidence emanates from remains of paper, skin, stone, etc. from preceding eras. But verbal evidence emerges in response to ...
Memories of Ali Fadaei

Only a Persian Melon Has Remained!

Ali Fadaei, one of warriors of the holy defense, was narrator of 289th session of memory night. On the sidelines of this program, correspondent of Iranian Oral History Website interviewed him. In the following text, you read other memories of the Holy Defense warrior.

The Narration of a Teenager in Book "The Soldiers of Niar"

The book "The Soldiers of Niar " includes a narration of the memoirs of a teenager (aged 15), named Kalamolah Akbarzadeh during the eight years of holy defense. He was born in the village of Niar, the environs of Ardabil province. This book was published by Sassan Nategh in 1396(2017).

Memoirs from the world of sports and athletes

The interest in athletes is one of the interests that have existed in different periods, our fathers have loved the athletes, and we are the same. This interest is beyond generations and age. In recent years, Golgasht have translated and released books about the life of foreign athletes through recognizing the interest. “David Beckham”, “I Am Zlatan”, “Fear and Loathing in La Liga” and “The Soul of a Butterfly” are the titles of some of these books. First, it is better to review every one of these books.